18 Brooke Davis and Peyton Sawyer (Sophia Bush and Hilarie Burton) as Goth Rocker and Devil in One Tree Hill
Best friends Brooke and Peyton were also sometimes rivals during One Tree Hill’s high school years, because at one time or another they are both into the same guy. Eye-grabbing costumes at Peyton’s Halloween party are a must then, with both staying true to their roots: Peyton went hot rocker goth, and Brooke does what she does best in a shamelessly slutty devil costume.
